Learning from the BP Oil Disaster
Although every major oil company operating in
deep water around the world had guaranteed that it could handle a
blowout, not a single one knew what to do.
The Deepwater Horizon drilling rig exploded off the coast of
Louisiana one year ago, killing 11 crewmembers and ultimately releasing
some 210 million gallons of oil. It became the largest oil disaster in
American history. It could happen again.
Keith Jones didn't need to wait for the phone call. He knew the
moment he saw the images of the April 20, 2010 explosion on television
that his son was dead. Gordon, age 28, had a two-year-old son and a
pregnant wife, Michelle, eagerly waiting for him at home. He was on the
rig for just a one-week tour before heading home for the birth of his
second child. Had he not volunteered to stay on for an extra shift
because his coworker was tired, he might have made it home.
On that April day, BP lost a game of chicken it had long played with
the Macondo oil well. Dubbed the "Well from Hell," the oil buried 18,500
feet below the ocean's surface had made it clear time and again that it
had no intention of being pumped out of the earth. But BP refused to
listen.
BP wasn't alone. Government regulators, playing out their overly
intimate and trusting relationship with the oil industry, rubber-stamped
every cost-cutting and progressively deadly decision. Transocean, the
largest operator of oil and gas rigs in the world, and Halliburton, the
world's largest energy services company, among others, operated with
failed--and possibly criminal--procedures.
It was only after the explosion and the heart-rending stream of
photos of oil-soaked birds that we all learned a terrible secret:
although every major oil company operating in deep water around the
world had guaranteed that it could handle a blowout, not a single one
knew what to do. Instead, the industry's supposed emergency-response
experts spent three long months learning on the fly, applying
shallow-water technology suitable for wells at 400 or less feet below
the ocean's surface to a deepwater blowout 5,000 feet below the surface.
Five months and nearly 5 million barrels of oil later, a newly
drilled relief well finally sealed Macondo's gusher. There is no way to
speed the drilling of such a well. Thus, if another deepwater blowout
occurs, it is all but guaranteed that another massive release of oil is
in our future.
Although each major oil company operating in the Gulf had certified
that it could handle a gusher of 300,000 barrels of oil per day, none
could. At its worst, the Macondo well released 80,000 barrels of oil per
day. Yet no company had ships that could hold even a fraction of that
oil, adequate booms to contain it, or adequate skimmers to suck it up.
Instead, in a case of the cure being worse than the disease, nearly 2
million gallons of toxic chemical dispersants were simultaneously mixed
into the water and sprayed from the air to break the oil up, while at
least 410 fires were ignited on the water's surface to burn the oil
away. For those living in, on, and from the water, the impacts of the
oil, dispersants, and fires are profound and ongoing.
The Deepwater Horizon tragedy isn't over. Oil and dispersants still
line the bottom of the ocean, waiting for the next wave or hurricane to
wash them ashore. What's not on the ocean floor is the sea life that
once abounded there. Missing from the waters are the baby oysters and
shrimp on which the fishers' 'livelihoods depend. The ocean continues to
wash up dead fish, dolphins, and other sea life. Oily tar balls still
dot the beaches. Local residents still suffer "the BP cough."
And the local economy has yet to recover. A mere 40 percent of the
claims filed for those economically harmed by the disaster have even
been processed, much less paid.
A few months after the explosion, Keith Jones told me that when his
older grandson started talking in full sentences, he asked the question
he'd held in his head all along: "Where is my daddy?"
On the BP oil disaster's one-year anniversary, it's time to learn its
most important lesson: deepwater drilling isn't safe or worth the risk. |